gsoc01

Trade is one for one: Grant Hardie for Robin Brydone.

How often do we see anything come close to resembling a trade in curling? That’s what it looked like on paper, at least, when British Curling announced Monday its slate of performance programme teams for next season.

Hardie, who spent nine successful seasons on the back end with Bruce Mouat, is now at the helm of Ross Whyte’s team, throwing third stones and skipping the renamed Team Hardie. Brydone heads the other way to join Mouat at third.

Just a typical early June in the curling world.

Could this shocking one-for-one "trade" turn into a win-win deal and benefit both teams? Let’s take a deep dive into that, plus other curling tidbits, in Eight Ends.

FIRST END: Although the info came out in one seismic wave, let's dial it back and look at it step by step.

The word on the sheet all season was that Hardie was thinking about leaving Team Mouat at the conclusion of the Olympic quad, possibly even stepping back from curling altogether.

Hardie addressed the rumours on the latest episode of the Broom Brothers podcast. He explained that his desire to compete in the sport was still there, but after nine years, two Olympic silver medals, two world championships and 12 Grand Slams, he felt he needed a new challenge and wondered if he would still have the same drive with Team Mouat.

Joining Whyte & Co. satisfies that condition. Not only will Hardie be throwing third stones, but he will also be calling the shots. How Hardie will fare as a skip is a valid question — and it will take some time for him to fit in and learn the dynamics of his new squad — but let’s not forget that he has skipped on tour in the past. Hardie even made his Grand Slam of Curling series debut as a skip at the 2017 Champions Cup before joining Team Mouat the following season.

Let’s just be thankful Hardie didn’t request a trade to Florida, Minnesota or Vegas.

From Team Mouat’s perspective, with Hardie wanting to move on, who better than Brydone to replace him? Brydone would have been an excellent replacement regardless, even if Hardie didn’t link up with Whyte and make a clean one-for-one swap possible. Mouat and Brydone go way back, with Brydone serving as Mouat’s alternate when he skipped Scotland to gold at the world juniors in 2016. They also played together on Northern United during the debut season of Rock League in April.

Come to think of it, Hardie skipped a game for Frontier Curling Club against Mouat's Northern United crew and won. It would be funny if Rock League played a hand in all of this.

So, who wins the trade? Call it a cop out, but cue the Old El Paso "why not both" meme, as it's a good fit for both teams.

The real answer will come in three years when British Curling has to decide which team will be heading to France for the 2030 Olympic Winter Games.

SECOND END: It's interesting to look at how Team Mouat and Team Whyte (er, make that the Team Formerly Known as Whyte) stack up statistically over the previous two seasons.

World Rankings: Mouat has had the No. 1 spot on lockdown since August 2024. Whyte has been consistently among the top five and reached as high as No. 3 this past January when he won the Crown Royal Players’ Championship, the crown jewel of the Grand Slam of Curling.

International: Mouat won gold at the World Men’s Curling Championship last year and earned an Olympic silver medal in Milano Cortina. Whyte took home bronze at the worlds this year.

Scottish Men's Curling Championship: Whyte has won the past three national titles.

Head-to-Head: Mouat holds a 5-4 advantage over their past nine games they've played against each other, but of Whyte’s wins, two came in Grand Slam semifinals, plus another high-profile matchup in the 2025 Scottish final. (Sidenote: Team Mouat, minus Mouat, also defeated Team Whyte in the preliminary round of the AMJ Shorty Jenkins Classic last season. Hardie skipped as Mouat was attending a wedding, so we left it out of the statistics here.)

Grand Slam of Curling: All 10 Grand Slam of Curling tournaments over the past two seasons featured either Mouat or Whyte in the men’s final. Mouat appeared in six finals and won all six of them, while Whyte appeared in four and won two. Strangely, they haven’t faced off in a Grand Slam final … yet.

GSOC 2025-26 All-Stars: Mouat was the top men’s skip, shooting 84.85 per cent over the season, but Team Whyte cleaned up the front end awards with second Craig Waddell at 83.15 per cent and lead Euan Kyle at 89.48 per cent. Hardie made the second all-star team at third, shooting 81.54 per cent, alongside Team Mouat second Bobby Lammie at 81.80 per cent. For what it’s worth, Brydone was right behind Hardie in third place at their position, shooting 80.79 per cent. Whyte was the top team overall at 83.66 per cent, with Mouat in second at 83.28 per cent.

THIRD END: Somewhat lost in the shuffle of the team changes, Kyle Waddell’s team will remain intact for next season and don’t underestimate them.

Waddell emerged as a threat this past season, cracking the top 10 in the world rankings and finishing runner-up to Whyte at both the Crown Royal Players’ Championship and the Scottish Men’s Curling Championship. When Waddell wasn’t busy with his own team, he also served as the alternate for Team Mouat, adding a bronze from the European Curling Championships and a silver from the Winter Olympics to his haul of medals.

Waddell’s teammates Mark Watt, Angus Bryce and Blair Haswell are all in their mid-20s and are only going to get better.

FOURTH END: You have to feel bad for Duncan McFadzean, who had played with Whyte for a decade but was left off the roster for the new Team Hardie. McFadzean missed almost all of last season recovering from a knee injury, leading to Craig Waddell joining full-time and thriving in the role.

It’s one thing if it were skill-related, but it’s tough to see someone lose their spot due to injury.

McFadzean will still be part of the performance programme, playing mixed doubles with Sophie Jackson. They’ve shown promise in the past, winning the Scottish mixed doubles title in 2024 and finishing runners-up in 2023 and 2025. They’ll be in a tough spot in the division as Jennifer Dodds, who plays mixed doubles with Mouat, will be focusing on the discipline as well next season.

FIFTH END: Although Scotland boasts three of the top men’s teams in the world, there will be only one women’s team in British Curling’s performance programme, skipped by Fay Henderson. With Rebecca Morrison not returning to the sport, her teammates have gone their separate ways. Jackson and Dodds are on mixed doubles duty, as previously mentioned, while Sophie Sinclair has joined Henderson as a fifth player.

Henderson is the three-time reigning national champion and finished 10th at the women’s worlds this year with a 4-8 record. The team has potential to grow as Henderson, third Lisa Davie, second Laura Watt and lead Katie McMillan are all 25 or younger. The addition of Sinclair should help with experience at the Winter Olympics on her resume.

Henderson finished the season ranked No. 37 in the world, but you have to scroll all the way down to No. 127 to find the next Scottish women’s team, skipped by Tia Laurie. The depth isn’t there at the moment compared to the men’s division.

SIXTH END: There’s one more Scottish team, or part Scottish team, to discuss outside of British Curling’s performance programme. Cameron Bryce announced last month his new lineup, retaining Scott Hyslop and Robin McCall while adding Kerr Drummond and Karsten Sturmay. Drummond, who won two medals at the world juniors for Scotland, lives in Canada and is a three-time Brier competitor, while the Edmonton-born Sturmay, a silver medallist for Canada at the 2019 Winter Universiade, now lives in the U.K.

A multiple-country "mercenary" team might be the only thing rarer in curling than a one-for-one trade, but it makes sense in this scenario. When the big three of Mouat, Hardie and Waddell are likely to have a hold on international selection for the next quad, why not focus on the tour and put together the best possible lineup regardless of borders? The five-player rotation also allows them to use different lineup combinations depending on which side of the pond they’re playing and helps cut down on travel expenses.

As Bryce explained to colleague John Cullen, although he believes his chances of representing Scotland again on the international stage are low, this could provide an opportunity for someone like his 24-year-old teammate Hyslop to remain on the radar.

Remember, nothing is stopping a multiple-country team from competing in the Grand Slam of Curling. We've seen it in the past with teams calling upon spares from outside of their borders (something we’ll explore in a future Eight Ends this summer). The new qualification process for the Grand Slam of Curling, with winners of Satellite Events receiving direct entry spots, also makes it possible for a mercenary team to fast-track into the series.

It’s a unique case, and Bryce might not end up being a trend-setter, but I wouldn't be surprised if another skip is taking notes and forms their own mercenary team.

SEVENTH END: Here’s a more typical June curling announcement as reigning Olympic gold medallist Anna Hasselborg announced last week her team is sticking together for another cycle, with the only change being that longtime alternate Johanna Heldin has stepped back. The Swedish squad wasn’t the most dominant in the previous quad but returned to form at the right moments, winning gold for a second time in Milano Cortina.

The team has also won eight Grand Slam of Curling titles together — the only women’s team to win all five active events in the series, in fact — and three European gold medals. The only trophy missing is a world championship, with two silver medals at that event.

Hasselborg will aim for a return to the podium in 2030, but expect compatriot Isabella Wranå to loom as a larger threat. Wranå also came home from Milano Cortina with a gold medal in mixed doubles and edged out Hasselborg in a points race to represent Sweden at the world championship for the first time this year, where she earned bronze. Both of those experiences should serve as a big confidence boost moving forward.

EIGHTH END: If you thought we had reached the finish line with British Curling's announcement, there are still a few other team roster changes that we're anticipating before we can close the book on our 2026-27 lineup tracker.

USA Curling should announce its high performance program teams soon, the first under newly appointed high performance director Brad Gushue. We know changes are afoot as both Chris Plys and Colin Hufman from John Shuster’s team already announced they’re stepping back, and who knows, there might be more twists to come.

Overseas, who will play third for Satsuki Fujisawa following Chinami Yoshida’s departure? Tori Koana has the inside track, having served as the team’s alternate at the women’s worlds earlier this year and subbing in for Yoshida for a handful of games. Koana is also playing third with the team this week at the Japanese Curling Championships. If all goes well, that would be the natural fit. Koana has prioritized mixed doubles in recent years but won the national title as a skip in 2018. We've seen enough thirds moving to skip this off-season; it's about time someone pulls the reversal.